You have found the home of Japanese Mini LP Papersleeve Replica CDs on the net
HomeBrowse FAQs (Fakes, Buying, Collecting) Fake-free eBayForumContributeMy Collection
Do not go here or you will be banned from this site!
ThumbsThis week / monthRecent images
Random images from
(Very basic search - less is better - use less words if don't find what you're looking for)
<< Prev FAQs - Miscellaneous Next >>
What is the difference between a "bootleg" and a "pirate"? E-mail

Firstly, collectively these are often simply refered to as "unauthorised" recordings or releases.

Even that rather broad term is misleading as there are ocassionally local releases that are not meant to be exported outside the country where they are issued. Of course, if these are attractive they will wind up on eBay - especially if there's a foreign buck to be made.

Also, what the artist wants is sometimes not exactly what the recording company wants. I imagine also that sometimes a blind eye is turned - especially if the inclusion of an "unauthorised" box is likely to increase sales.

With the above in mind - here's a more traditional opinion on the difference.

  "Bootleg"
(or boot)
"Pirate"
(or forgery or counterfeit)
General Material that has never been offered by the owner of the work for commercial release (nothing to do with whiskey or gin). An illegal copy of an official commercial release.
Recording A recording that was obtained without the artist's consent. An unauthorised copy of an official commercial release (eg. a CDR or tape copy of a CD or vinyl album).
Packaging Packaging that portrays an artist's work that has been designed without the artist's consent or draws on commercial designs released in another context. Akin to a forgery.  A near exact copy of an official commercial release.

Bootleg Recording Examples:

  • The Beatles sing "Happy Birthday" at your birthday party and you tape it and sell it.
  • You are the engineer at a recording studio and you obtain your own copies from recording sessions made by Brian Eno and David Byrne and release these on vinyl.
  • You record an mp3 of a concert performance on your phone and share it on the net.

Pirate Recording Example:

  1. A tape or CDR made by a friend and given to you.
  2. A tape or CDR made by you for use in your car.
  3. A silver factory CD made to look like the real thing (usually accompanied by pirate packaging).

Bootleg Packaging Example:

  1. A bootleg recording, professionally presented on silver CD in glossy packaging is considered to be contained in bootleg packaging.

Pirate Packaging Example:

  1. A deliberate copy of the real thing, sold on ebay as if it was the original. (Ocassionally the seller may not even know it's a pirate.)

Here are some examples of a professionally produced "pirate" (both recording and packaging):

  1. Russian conterfeit version of Jethro Tull's Broadsword and the Beast.
  2. Aerosmith Pump - Real or Fake?

Here is an example of how confusing and even morally challenging it can all be: Exciting The Who. This is a professionally produced unauthorised release, containing pirate CDs (copies of real studio recordings) each CD housed in mini-LP packaging. Even those these covers mimic official Japanese LP releases, they have never officially been released as CD covers. Does this mean the covers are pirates or bootlegs? Who knows?

In reality though the artist is unlikely to have received any royalties for this release. Despite this, many (perhaps most?) collectors would agree it's a lovely item and would like to own it.

Generally speaking in the Mini-LP world

Most promo boxes are just that - an outer box designed to hold the real thing and originally "given away" as an incentive to buy the full set of current releases.

Further Reading

UK second hand dealer "More Music" has a series of nice articles on both the history of bootlegs and recording piracy.

To quote "While Collectors have a healthy respect for the bootlegger, piracy has few friends. Pirates are generally second generation copies, while the fan may get a pirate cheaply, they are unlikely to get a quality recording, even less likely to get the full sleeve and artwork ... whatever you think of the global record companies, they do pay royalties to the artists you like, manufacturers of pirates do not; they are wholly parasitic on the music industry."

 
<< Prev FAQs - Miscellaneous Next >>

Featured Releases (A selection of...)

See all Featured Releases

Front cover (main) image of DU-BOX226L : Schulze, Klaus : Timewind Box
DU-BOX226L : 2008-02-22
Big box to enclose the previous 3 slipcase promoboxes released by Disk Union to hold a total of 16 albums.
Front cover (main) image of hudson-pf01 : Pink Floyd : Hudson Dark Side of the Moon Box
hudson-pf01 : 2008-01-01

A unique creation from Kerry Hudson design. Lavishly sculptured and finished, this felt lined wooden box stand holds all regular sized Pink Floyd Mini vinyl LP replica covers along with a selection of DVDs.

The ultimate gift for the Pink Floyd fan who has everything. (The box is currently for sale from the sculptor. Contact details can be found here.)

This was Kerry's second homage to an artist's releases on Mini LP, the first being Hudson Genesis Box Mach I.

 
Front cover (main) image of TOCP-65740 : Pink Floyd : The Dark Side Of The Moon
TOCP-65740 : 2001-06-16
The landmark 1973 album from Pink Floyd. This issue contains all the original inserts plus more.
Front cover (main) image of UICY-94827 : Mike Oldfield : Q.E.2 Deluxe Edition
UICY-94827 : 2012-09-12
Universal Music : Cardboard sleeve (mini LP) reissue from Mike Oldfield featuring the high-fidelity SHM-CD format (compatible with standard CD players) and using the remaster audio made in UK in 2012. The cardboard sleeve faithfully replicates the UK first press LP plus a cardboard sleeve jacket based on a new design. Comes with a description written by Mike Oldfield himself and lyrics. Part of a two-album Mike Oldfield SHM-CD cardboard sleeve reissue series featuring albums "Platinum" and "Q.E.2."
 
Front cover (main) image of EMICD-11228 : Pink Floyd : Oh By The Way: European Box Set
EMICD-11228 : 2007-11-26

16 CD box set - being 14 studio albums including 2 doubles.

According to Pink Floyd Brain Damage site there were a few glitches with this release, the most notable being a misprinting of the inner bag for the second CD in "The Wall".

There are also cases of an album being missed out and duplicates in their places.

The later Japanese release of this box set is basically identical to this box set.

Poor quality fakes exist for this set - more details below.

The original Japanese individual releases are regarded as being of a much higher quality to either of these box sets.

You can see a YouTube video of this set on the videos page.

Front cover (main) image of WPCR-13142 (fake) : Led Zeppelin : Fake Led Zeppelin - 40th Anniversary Definitive Collection (Zoso Box)
WPCR-13142 (fake) : 2009-01-01

This fake Led Zeppelin 40th Anniversary appears to be made in China. You would find it hard to pick a sealed copy of this as being anything other than than the real deal.

Inside it is also remarkably similar but has some significant, obvious differences in packaging including: (a) the CD comes in a flimsy loose fitting bag (b) Physical Graffiti has no cut out windows and (c) III (3) has no turning wheel.

The CDs also have the tell tale extra ring in the middle but this is much better disguised than usual.

Unusually for fakes these have the catalogue number and an IFPI code (CC 303) on the silver side of the disc.

 

See all Featured Releases